95 Comments

Walter Kirn had an interesting observation yesterday: AI performance is highly correlated with energy consumption. That makes AI a parasite on a critical resource - and perhaps, one day, a predator.

https://x.com/walterkirn/status/1832981734876717458?t=1wVrGM4q9FSw4yLF_EOnuQ&s=19

Expand full comment

What if … just what if … extracting energy from air (wind) is NOT “renewable”, but is more like draining a battery or an oil reservoir?

Expand full comment

would love to hear your thoughts on the recent PJM auction as it relates to coal and electricity supply/demand in the medium and long term. Thanks for all you do!

Expand full comment

The world's countries as a whole generated 1,870.3 terawatt hours (TWh) of wind energy in 2021 so you think they should stop and replace windmills with coal power ? Why ?

Expand full comment

And you can’t seem to use google either .

What in the world makes you think I don’t read EIA ?

Expand full comment

Why don't all the energy haters give up energy use? And "yes", that's a serious question.

Expand full comment

So how horrific will a Harris Presidency coupled with a Democratic controlled Congress?

How much more economic contraction will be imposed , all in the name of climate change mitigation?

Expand full comment

Well, write in Doomberg, on your Pres 2024 Ballot, you might not go to the kulak with the MAGA's? Kamala will get the ballots to win no matter what. usa is banana republic and a colony of CHINA#1. Covid came from a cute Racoon, like the Truthy = MSM Atlantic https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2023/03/covid-origins-research-raccoon-dogs-wuhan-market-lab-leak/673390/ OR LIAR Guest Opinon NYT == https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/06/03/opinion/covid-lab-leak.html COMMRADs support the BLOB, CHINA#1 IS MFG all usa needs with COAL. Export the Emissions along the jobs. Hitler=TRUMP is not a choice.

Expand full comment

Mr. Bryce,

After reading your article, I have to compliment you once again for nailing it to the point. This time, I also have to commend you for making me laugh out loud multiple times, especially with "tutti frutti hydrogen." 😂 You certainly have a remarkable talent for comedy. Have you ever considered writing a Hollywood movie script?

Expand full comment

I've been an advocate for nuclear power for nearly 40 years, when in high school my physics teacher taught me the science behind a nuclear explosion. This was in the 1970s, and I thought this was the answer to all our energy needs. I am ashamed that our congressional leaders haven't understood that wind and solar will never provide the energy we need going forward. Massive spending and subsidies for those technologies will never produce the power needed going forward.

Expand full comment

The subsidies for wind and solar are a giant malinvestment and are a red line for me. Support them and you don't get my vote.

Expand full comment

China is now building 95% of all of the new coal plants in the world. https://www.carbonbrief.org/china-responsible-for-95-of-new-coal-power-construction-in-2023-report-says/

Expand full comment

CHINA#1 IMPORTER of usa Emissions and JOBS!

Expand full comment

Thank you, Robert, for taking the effort to inform and educate us in the area of Global Power Demand. I always look forward to your writings.

Expand full comment

Robert, you continue to inform and inspire me with your commentary.

Expand full comment

1 MW of capacity in 2009 produced 4,312 MWh of electricity. In 2020, 1 MW of capacity generated 3,094 MWh, a decline of 28.3 percent. It’s as clear as can be: investment in renewables shrinks the economy’s productive potential.

Expand full comment

Not being political here, but any politician who supports wind turbines in any way (other than supporting their removal) should have their homes wired with a "Sgt. Schultz-Schmaht-Lectrick -Metur" that supplies voltage correlated with local wind or closest wind "farm". No using a fossil fuel generator to make it up, but they can buy all the batteries they want, install roof top solar, geothermal or a micro-SMR.

Expand full comment

I'm a bit skeptical about China increasing electricity usage by 6.5% this year. That's about 50% above the country's expected growth weight. However, it could be true if they are being wasteful -- lots of energy to build houses and factories and offices that go unused.

Expand full comment