44 Comments

Great description of the current situation. My personal prediction is that net zero is going to be recalculated to 2150 as opposed to 2050 since we are certainly at least a century away from the technology necessary to power the lifestyles we currently have, let alone improvements, without burning fossil fuels

Expand full comment

No less important is access to clean water. The health impacts are immediate, and laying a water pipe frees enormous amounts of time spent each day in walking and carrying water, predominantly done by women in poorer areas. It needs some sort of pump power, such as electricity, but is surely one of the most effective uses of energy for making life better among the poorest.

Expand full comment

Oops Robert isn't that being a bit Sexist and Patronizing in this day and age.

What you meant to say is, that without electricity women are unable to use the electric lawnmower to mow the lawn, trim the edges, cut the hedge and use the leaf blower.

Expand full comment

Japan should be returning to nuclear too. Before three of the six reactors at Fukushima Daiichi (Number 1) were damaged by the tsunami after the Tohoku earthquake, the station was among the 15th largest in the world, in terms of total generating capacity. The generators were not damaged by the earthquake, but three of the six (units 1, 2, and 3) were damaged by coolant failure because the auxiliary generators and switchgear were in the basements, which were not waterproof. The building of unit 4 was damaged by a hydrogen explosion in unit 3. Fukushima Daini (Number 2) has essentially identical reactors. Its buildings' lower levels were submerged by the tsunami, but they are waterproof and fuel is on high ground, so the auxiliary generators and their switchgear kept coolant flowing and the reactors were not damaged. Japan should restart Fukushima Daiichi units 4, 5, and 6, with their auxiliary generators and switchgear and fuel on high ground or in waterproof rooms, and build the two planned additional units. Read the full story in Chapter 9 at http://vandyke.mynetgear.com/Whence-Energy.html

Expand full comment

Very informative article, Robert. Despite the pledge you recently mentioned of multi-billionaire Michael Bloomberg to spend a billion dollars for his "beyond hydrocarbons" campaign, the economics of using coal for electricity generation and industrial processes insures the planet will be using copious amounts of coal for decades (or centuries) to come.

Expand full comment

Thanks for the great article.

I have personally worked for 4 years in Rwanda to extend the distribution network and connect entire villages to the national grid. It is a game changer when you have electricity.

As one Rwandan lady told me: “Now I can finally see the beauty of my village during the night”.

Expand full comment
Oct 25, 2023·edited Oct 25, 2023

I've seen a video of herders in Pakistan walking their sheep to new pastures. And an old woman in the group couldn't keep up so they just left her to die. And I imagine it's the same for someone badly injured, even a broken leg, left to die.

Check these videos from a farmer in Kenya. Woman pack 20l jugs of water on their heads walking 2km to try (and often fail) to keep their farm & livestock functioning. You can pump 10,000 gal of water the same distance with 1 gal of fossil fuel. They would love to have oil to do that back breaking work for them:

"...Good morning from Kisii Kenya.

What is it like to live here without fossil fuels?

Some refer to it as 'Sustainable', I agree, only if its definition changes to 'break your back if you want to eat even though you'll be poor forever'..."

https://twitter.com/JusperMachogu/status/1642391693075836928?s=20

https://juspermachogu.substack.com/

https://greenleapforward.substack.com/p/spilling-the-beans-farming-without

https://greenleapforward.substack.com/p/yet-another-jusper-thread

Expand full comment

If you aren't censoring comments behind a paywall: now that global climate destruction is a demonstrated fact, the Fossilized Industry is now making the case that to show we really care about the disenfranchised poor women of the world, we must leverage coal and other fossils. Good PR firms you can afford to hire.

Expand full comment

great article on coal ... but I think you need to take it a step further and urge the West to develop nuclear like gangbusters because it will take time to develop and grow the companies and workforce (engineers, trades, operators) to learn how to do it cheaply enough it can be exported to replace coal plants all over the world, including the US, Japan, Germany etc ... wherever there is a coal plant it should be replaced by nuclear - it will take decades but we should be starting now

Expand full comment

Wyoming allowed women to vote before Colorado did.

Expand full comment

There is one irony that is again putting women (who usually do the family laundry) back to the washtub (i.e., sink). The continual energy-standards degradation of washing machines has resulted in clothing not getting cleaned, even if one sets the washer to deep level and two rinses.

Some women with children (who are rough on clothing, stain-wise) or who want clean clothing are resorting to prewashing by hand in the sink before inserting the clothing into the washer. The non-elected government energy-saving bureaucrats have pushed women back into the washtub age.

Expand full comment

I'm old enough to remember life without electricity. Every time I sit with a cup of coffee and hear the washing machine and dryer cleaning the laundry and the dishwasher doing the dishes, I am thankful. Kerosene lanterns and outhouses are vivid memories. The current push to go backwards is ridiculous.

Expand full comment

The Big River keeps rolling on!

Expand full comment

Thank you, this is a great piece. I will be sure to send to my knucklehead sister. A long time ago I remember reading women in third world countries who were lucky enough to get cellphones were more apt to create revenue by charging phone time to neighbors thus bring money and food to their immediate families. They would invest back in their families at a higher percentage than men. The elites don’t seem to understand the ripple effect. I really appreciate you work and send it to my boys and so yes, I will subscribe

Expand full comment

We need to break free of idiot government. "Woke" is a poor description of a government that is asleep at the switch when it comes to simple common sense.

Expand full comment

Excellent comprehensive piece, Robert. Keep smacking the idiots over the head with science and logic. The cracks are forming. We will win.

Expand full comment